Skip to main content
ClinicalSim
Back to Insights
5 min read

What the HCAHPS overall rating tracks most closely

In CMS's HCAHPS table (2.5 million surveys, 2025), nurse communication (0.67) tracks the overall hospital rating. What that cannot promise a nursing leader.

ClinicalSim Team

ClinicalSim

Nurse leaders are often asked what moves the HCAHPS overall rating, and the question usually arrives with a request for a training program. It helps to look first at what the HCAHPS survey measures and which parts of the stay a patient's rating travels with. CMS publishes that table every year, and the first one for the updated survey came out on November 12, 2026 [1].

What does the HCAHPS overall rating measure?

The HCAHPS overall rating is one survey question: "Using any number from 0 to 10, where 0 is the worst hospital possible and 10 is the best hospital possible, what number would you use to rate this hospital during your stay?" [2]. A second global question asks whether the patient would recommend the hospital to friends and family. In the October 2026 public report, the average hospital's top-box score was 72% for the rating (the share of its patients giving a 9 or 10) and 71% for "definitely" recommending, across 3,940 hospitals [3, 4].

Communication with Nurses is a composite of three questions about how often nurses treated the patient with courtesy and respect, listened carefully, and explained things in a way the patient could understand [2]. Courtesy and a clear explanation are the same behaviors AIDET names as acknowledge and explain. The national average top-box score, the share answering "always", was 80%, level with Communication with Doctors [3].

Which HCAHPS measure tracks the overall rating most closely?

CMS answers this with a patient-level correlation table, which shows how closely each measure moves with the two global items across every completed survey. In the table for January to December 2025 discharges (2.5 million surveys), Care Coordination correlated 0.69 with the hospital rating and Communication with Nurses 0.67. Communication with Doctors was 0.59 [1].

HCAHPS measureHospital ratingRecommend the hospital
Care Coordination0.690.62
Communication with Nurses0.670.60
Communication with Doctors0.590.54
Restfulness of Hospital Environment0.580.50
Responsiveness of Hospital Staff0.570.50
Communication About Medicines0.520.47
Information About Symptoms0.510.46
Cleanliness of Hospital Environment0.440.38
Discharge Information0.350.33
Patient-level correlations with the two HCAHPS global items, January to December 2025 discharges, 2.5 million surveys (CMS) [1]

Care Coordination is new. It entered the survey with January 2025 discharges, and its three questions ask whether doctors, nurses and other hospital staff were informed and up to date, worked well together, and planned with the patient and family for care after discharge [2]. It overlaps heavily with nurse communication: the two measures correlate 0.68 with each other [1].

On the previous version of the survey, Communication with Nurses was the measure most closely correlated with both global items. For July 2023 to June 2024 discharges (2.2 million surveys) it correlated 0.66 with the hospital rating and 0.60 with recommending the hospital, ahead of Communication with Doctors at 0.56 and 0.52 [5].

These tables pair one measure with one global item at a time. They are not a model that separates each measure's own contribution.

What happens when the measures are held against each other?

One hospital-level study did separate them, on the previous survey. Belasen and colleagues analyzed public HCAHPS results for 3,382 US hospitals from October 2017 to September 2018 [6]. Taken one at a time, Care Transition (0.866) and nurse communication (0.856) correlated most with the overall rating, and doctor communication followed at 0.763.

With the other composites held constant, the partial correlations were 0.445 for Care Transition, 0.369 for nurse communication and 0.066 for doctor communication [6]. Nurse and doctor communication correlated 0.807 with each other, so the small doctor figure means doctor communication adds little once the other measures are counted. It doesn't mean physicians' conversations don't matter to patients.

The study covers one year and one global item, and it describes an association. Care Transition is also not among the publicly reported measures of the updated survey [2], so the analysis would need repeating with Care Coordination in its place.

Do patient-level studies agree?

Two patient-level studies point the same way, with the same limit. In a hierarchical linear model of 85,766 patients at 100 hospitals in one health system, surveyed from July 2013 to October 2014, the coefficient on the nursing composite was 1.91 and the coefficient on the doctor composite was 0.48 [7]. The nursing composite was the three HCAHPS nurse communication questions. The authors wrote that the study was cross-sectional and could establish an association, not cause and effect.

In a regression on 112,283 surveys from 89 trauma centers in one hospital system, nurses accounted for 63.9% of the variation (adjusted R-squared) in the overall rating among trauma patients, 59.6% among surgical patients and 58.4% among medical patients [8]. That is a share of statistical variation, which is still an association. We have read that study's abstract and not the full paper.

Why nurses, and what the correlations can't say

Belasen and colleagues suggest the plainest explanation: patients spend more time communicating with their nurses than with their doctors [6]. The nurse is the person who explains the delay, answers the family's question at 3 a.m. and notices that the patient didn't follow the plan. It would be strange if the rating didn't travel with those conversations.

That makes nurses the reason patients rate a stay well. It doesn't follow that a hospital can raise the rating by working on the nurse communication score. Every figure above is a correlation between answers the same patient gave on the same form, and a patient who had a good stay tends to answer every question more favorably. The same authors note that the communication measures may reflect a single underlying impression of interpersonal care [6]. None of these studies tested what happens to the overall rating when nurse communication changes.

Which training programs improve HCAHPS nurse communication scores?

The correlation data can't answer that, because none of it tests a program. A hospital choosing a program should ask for a study with a comparison group and a named HCAHPS measure. The physician-side studies, where training rarely showed up in HCAHPS unless feedback reached the individual clinician, are summarized in HCAHPS can't see a single conversation.

Our own boundary is the one stated on the nursing page. ClinicalSim does not predict HCAHPS scores, and no current evidence shows that its practice scores change them. What practice can offer a nurse is a chance to rehearse the three things the survey asks patients about (respect, careful listening and clear explanation) with an AI patient, and to get feedback that quotes the nurse's own words, says what went well and names what to try next. That feedback is formative. Each nurse sees their own feedback, and leaders see only what the institution agrees to before anyone starts.

Any comparison with hospital survey data needs a separate study plan agreed before the practice starts. The plan should name the HCAHPS measure, the units, a comparison group and a time window. For the payment side of the same survey, see the impact of communication on hospital economics.

Where does Magnet recognition come in?

The question often comes from hospitals that hold or are pursuing Magnet recognition from the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC). ANCC's description of the Magnet Model says outcomes should be grouped as clinical outcomes related to nursing, workforce outcomes, patient and consumer outcomes, and organizational outcomes [9]. That page doesn't name HCAHPS, and this post makes no claim about what Magnet recognition requires.

ClinicalSim is not endorsed by, affiliated with, or approved by ANCC. Scores map to published frameworks; they do not establish compliance with any standard, which a surveyor determines against the institution's own policy.

References

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. HCAHPS patient-level correlations: January 2025 to December 2025 discharges. HCAHPS Online. Posted November 12, 2026. 2026.
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Crosswalk of updated HCAHPS survey questions to sub-measures. HCAHPS Online. 2025.
  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Summary of HCAHPS survey results: January 2025 to December 2025 discharges. HCAHPS Online. October 2026 public report. 2026.
  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Summary analyses. HCAHPS Online. 2026.
  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. HCAHPS patient-level correlations: July 2023 to June 2024 discharges. HCAHPS Online. Posted April 30, 2025. 2025.
  6. Belasen AT, Oppenlander J, Belasen AR, Hertelendy AJ. Provider-patient communication and hospital ratings: perceived gaps and forward thinking about the effects of COVID-19. Int J Qual Health Care. 2021;33(1):mzaa140. 2021. doi:10.1093/intqhc/mzaa140
  7. Otani K, Deng Y, Herrmann PA, Kurz RS. Patient satisfaction, quality attributes, and organizational characteristics: a hierarchical linear model approach. J Patient Exp. 2020;7(5):801-806. 2020. doi:10.1177/2374373519892410
  8. Watts DD, Slivinski A, Garland JM, et al. The impact of nursing on trauma patient satisfaction: an analysis of HCAHPS from 112,283 patients. J Trauma Nurs. 2021;28(4):219-227. 2021. doi:10.1097/JTN.0000000000000589
  9. American Nurses Credentialing Center. ANCC Magnet Model: creating a Magnet culture. American Nurses Association. Accessed November 15, 2026. 2026.