Skip to main content
ClinicalSim
Back to Insights
7 min read

Who should sit on your clinical competency committee

ACGME requires a clinical competency committee of at least three program faculty, one core. The 2020 guidebook calls five to seven members ideal.

VH

Vinod Havalad, MD

Chief Clinical Partnerships Officer, ClinicalSim

A clinical competency committee can only judge what its members, or the people whose assessments they read, have seen a resident do. The ACGME rules on who sits at that table are short, and most of what decides whether a committee can say anything defensible about a resident's communication sits in the choices a program director makes inside them.

What a clinical competency committee is

A clinical competency committee (CCC) is the group of faculty a residency program director appoints to review every resident's evaluations at least twice a year and decide each resident's progress on the specialty-specific Milestones, the ACGME's developmental levels for each competency in competency-based medical education (Common Program Requirements, Sections 5.3, 5.3.c, and 5.3.d, effective July 1, 2026). The committee meets before each resident's semi-annual evaluation and advises the program director on that resident's progress (Section 5.3.e).

What the ACGME requires of membership

The requirements themselves fit in two sentences. Section 5.3.a says the committee "must include three members of the program faculty, at least one of whom is a core faculty member," and Section 5.3.b says any additional members must be faculty from the same program or other programs, or "other health professionals who have extensive contact and experience with the program's residents."

The Background and Intent text under Section 5.3 fills in three details. Program faculty can include non-physicians who teach and evaluate residents, chief residents who have completed core residency in their specialty may serve, and nothing in the requirements limits the program director's own participation.

Who may not serve is spelled out in the ACGME's answers to frequently asked questions, printed with the 2026 requirements. Size, who chairs, and how long people serve are guidance rather than requirement, and that guidance comes mostly from the third edition of the ACGME's guidebook for programs (2020) and from a 2021 paper by three of its authors in the Journal of Graduate Medical Education.

How big should a clinical competency committee be?

Five to seven members, according to the guidebook, which cites the group-size literature in calling that range "generally considered ideal" and recommends no more than eight to 10 "for optimal committee functioning" (Andolsek et al., ACGME, 2020). Three is the floor because, in the guidebook's words, "three is the smallest number of individuals required for a truly good discussion." Ekpenyong, Padmore, and Hauer put the range at five to 10 and give the reason in one line: the committee has to be large enough to bring varied opinions and small enough that every member can contribute (Journal of Graduate Medical Education, 2021).

Program size changes the arithmetic. The guidebook defines small programs as fewer than 15 learners, medium as 15 to 75, and large as more than 75, and it says large programs "may need to have several CCCs," each of which still needs enough members and a thorough review process. A single committee for a large program asks every member to know more residents than any of them has worked with, and that is a staffing problem long before it shows up in a rating.

Who can sit on the committee, and who cannot

The guidebook names nurses, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, and social workers as the kind of health professionals Section 5.3.b allows, provided they have extensive contact with the program's residents. Ekpenyong and colleagues go further and suggest an interprofessional colleague who works alongside residents, such as a nurse or social worker, or a public member to represent patients' perspectives.

The exclusions are as specific, and most of them come from the FAQ appendix printed with the 2026 Common Program Requirements:

  • Residents and fellows. Residents in the accredited years of the program, chief residents included, may not serve as members or attend meetings, so that peers stay out of promotion, graduation, and remediation decisions. They can still give the chair or program director input through the evaluation system.
  • Chief residents still in the program. A chief who is a resident in the same ACGME-accredited program cannot serve. A chief who has completed core residency can, though the guidebook cautions that one who finished within the last year or two may be too close to the residents to be candid.
  • Program coordinators. A coordinator may attend at the program director's discretion to collate data, take minutes, and manage the Milestones submission, but may not be a voting member. The same FAQ notes that coordinators can offer insight on interpersonal and communication skills, teamwork, and professionalism through the program's evaluation system.

The program director can chair the committee, sit on it as a member, observe, or stay away. Some certifying boards and Review Committees restrict who can chair, and the guidebook's example is the American Board of Anesthesiology, which does not allow the program director to chair. The ACGME's FAQ tells programs to check with Review Committee staff for specialty guidance.

The guidebook also says that "some program directors find it extremely useful to have another faculty member chair the CCC," and that a program director who attends without chairing "should defer to the chair."

Why membership decides what the committee knows about communication

The guidebook's selection rule is one sentence: "CCC members should regularly teach and observe residents/fellows." Ekpenyong and colleagues make it a requirement of fairness, writing that the membership "must represent the diverse teachers who observe, supervise, and work with residents and fellows."

That rule matters for interpersonal and communication skills, a domain the ACGME's own documents say a committee can't rate well from a distance. ACGME's 2020 guidance on committee meetings says committees face challenges that can lead to sub-optimal Milestones reporting, and that this is "especially true when CCC members judge resident/fellow performance on milestones they themselves have not directly observed." The ACGME document behind the harmonized interpersonal and communication skills (ICS) Milestones says trainee performance in the domain "requires direct observations of skills in the patient care setting, with scenarios, or using simulation." And in a qualitative study of eight Transitional Year CCC members from four programs, none reported formal training for the role, and where assessment data was missing they assumed average performance and assigned a rating rather than marking the milestone Not Yet Assessable (Maranich et al., Journal of Graduate Medical Education, 2022).

For each resident on the agenda, then, the membership question is who at the table has watched that resident give bad news, run a family meeting, or hand off a sick patient, and if nobody has, whose written observation is the committee relying on? A committee that can't answer has a coverage gap, and Section 5.3.b already lets a program director fill it with a health professional who works beside residents every day.

How to run the table once it is built

A well-chosen committee can still go wrong in the room, and the guidance is specific about how to prevent it.

The chair should be an educator active in the program and, per Ekpenyong and colleagues, "an expert in Milestones and learner assessment as well as group process." The same paper suggests asking newer or junior members for their view before senior, influential members speak, so the first opinion voiced does not become the committee's.

Turnover needs a plan. The guidebook suggests staggered appointments "so that not everyone on the CCC turns over at once," which keeps the committee's shared sense of what each Milestone level looks like from walking out the door in a single June.

Members need training for the job they are doing. The guidebook says members must "engage in faculty development about their CCC role" and that all members "should participate in training on diversity, equity, inclusion, and bias." None of the eight committee members in the Maranich study reported formal CCC training, and this is the one gap on the list a program can close without changing who sits on the committee.

Where practice with AI patients fits

ClinicalSim is a voice-based AI patient simulation platform for practicing and measuring clinical communication in medical education. Residents hold spoken conversations with AI patients and see what they did well and what to practice next, and each encounter produces rubric scores with transcript evidence that faculty can review. That report is formative evidence and does not replace human judgment, so it can put a dated, reviewable record of a high-stakes conversation in front of a committee member who was not in the room, but it settles no promotion or remediation decision. Standardized patients remain stronger wherever a program needs a trained person who reacts in the moment and a faculty observer who sees what a transcript misses, and AI patient simulation can complement a standardized patient program rather than stand in for one.

A membership check before the next meeting

Before the next semi-annual review, a program director can run four checks against the current roster:

  1. Count members against program size. Fewer than three program faculty breaks Section 5.3.a, more than eight to 10 runs past the guidebook's recommended limit, and the guidebook says a large program may need several committees.
  2. List who on the committee directly observes residents with patients and families, by rotation. Any rotation with nobody on that list is a place the committee is rating communication secondhand.
  3. Check every chief resident and the coordinator against the exclusions above.
  4. Write down when each member's term ends and what CCC training each has had.

For what a committee needs in the file once membership is settled, see what a CCC needs before it can act on a communication problem. For the decisions that follow a committee's finding, see what belongs in a resident communication remediation plan, and for the communication evidence ClinicalSim can add to a committee's existing sources, see ClinicalSim for clinical competency committees.

References

  1. ACGME Common Program Requirements (Residency) including FAQs, Section 5.3, Background and Intent, and Section 5 FAQs, effective July 1, 2026. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. 2026.
  2. Andolsek K, Padmore J, Hauer KE, Ekpenyong A, Edgar L, Holmboe E. Clinical Competency Committees: a guidebook for programs, 3rd edition. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (archived copy). 2020.
  3. Ekpenyong A, Padmore JS, Hauer KE. The purpose, structure, and process of clinical competency committees: guidance for members and program directors. Journal of Graduate Medical Education 13(2s):45-50. 2021. doi:10.4300/JGME-D-20-00841.1
  4. Clinical Competency Committee: structure and membership. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (archived copy). 2020.
  5. Preparing for effective Clinical Competency Committee meetings. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. 2020.
  6. Morrison LJ, Joyce BL, Meyer LE, Moreland CJ, Puscas L, Regan L, Stephens MB, Roberts S, Edgar L. Strengthening interpersonal and communication skills assessment through harmonized milestones. Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education. Accessed October 26, 2026.
  7. Maranich AM, Hemmer PA, Uijtdehaage S, Battista A. ACGME Milestones in the real world: a qualitative study exploring response process evidence. Journal of Graduate Medical Education 14(2):201-209. 2022. doi:10.4300/JGME-D-21-00546.1