Miller's Pyramid
Miller's Pyramid is a four-level framework for assessing clinical competence, published by George Miller in Academic Medicine in 1990. The levels are knows, knows how, shows how, and does, moving from knowledge at the base to what a clinician does in real practice. Each level calls for a different assessment method.
Source: Miller GE, Academic Medicine, 1990
Miller's Pyramid is a four-level framework for assessing clinical competence that moves from knowledge at the base, up through the application of knowledge, then demonstration of a skill under observation, and finally what a clinician does in real practice. George Miller published the framework in Academic Medicine in 1990, in a five-page supplement paper titled The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance. He was making an argument rather than drawing a diagram: assessment in medical education had drifted toward what is convenient to test, and no volume of written examination tells you whether a physician can actually do the work.
Each level has its own methods. Knows and knows how are reachable with written and oral tests, from multiple choice questions through clinical problem-solving exercises. Shows how needs observed performance, which in practice means an OSCE or another station-based examination with a standardized patient. Does can only be reached by watching a clinician work with real patients over time, which is what workplace-based assessment and entrustment ratings are reaching for.
The framework earns its keep as a check on your own claims. A program that assesses communication with a knowledge quiz is sitting at the bottom of the pyramid while reporting on a competency near the top, and a competency committee looking only at in-training exam scores and rotation evaluations has no shows how evidence at all.
Later authors writing in Academic Medicine have proposed extending the pyramid upward, toward entrustment decisions about how much supervision a learner still needs and toward professional identity formation, meaning who the learner is becoming rather than what they can perform. The four original levels have held up well enough that most competency-based curricula still map onto them, which is part of why a 1990 supplement paper is still cited weekly.
What this looks like in a program
- Map every assessment in your curriculum to a level, then look hard at which competencies have no evidence above knows how.
- Assess communication with station-based observation rather than a written test, since shows how is the lowest level at which a conversation can be judged at all.
- Treat repeated practice as the bridge between knows how and shows how, because learners rarely make that jump from reading and lectures alone.
Common questions
What are the four levels of Miller's Pyramid?
Miller's Pyramid has four levels. Knows is factual knowledge, such as being able to list the steps of a protocol. Knows how is the ability to describe how those steps would be applied. Shows how is demonstrating the skill under observation, which is where an OSCE and other station-based examinations sit. Does is performing the skill with real patients over time. George Miller published the framework in Academic Medicine in 1990.
Who created Miller's Pyramid?
George Miller published the framework in Academic Medicine in 1990, in a paper titled The assessment of clinical skills/competence/performance. His argument was that assessment in medical education had drifted toward what is convenient to test, and that no volume of written examination tells you whether a physician can actually do the work. A written test can reach knows and knows how. Shows how needs observed performance.
Where does an OSCE sit on Miller's Pyramid?
An OSCE sits at shows how. The learner demonstrates a skill under observation, with a standardized patient or another station-based examination, rather than answering a question about the skill. Knows and knows how are the levels a written or oral test can reach. Does is performance with real patients over time, which workplace-based assessment is built to capture. An OSCE score is evidence of shows how, and it is not evidence of does.
Related terms
Last updated November 2026
Put the frameworks into practice
ClinicalSim maps voice-based practice to the competency framework that fits the learner's stage.
Discuss your communication priorities