Skip to main content
ClinicalSim

Clinical Judgment Model

Two different models share the name clinical judgment model. Tanner's Clinical Judgment Model, published in the Journal of Nursing Education in 2006, describes four phases: noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting. The NCSBN Clinical Judgment Measurement Model is a separate instrument for scoring judgment on the Next Generation NCLEX. The two are not interchangeable.

Source: Tanner, Journal of Nursing Education, 2006

Tanner's Clinical Judgment Model, drawn from a review of nearly 200 studies and published in the Journal of Nursing Education in 2006, sets out four phases: noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting. The NCSBN Clinical Judgment Measurement Model is a separate instrument, built to score clinical judgment inside a standardized licensure examination, and it underpins the Next Generation NCLEX that launched on April 1, 2023. British and Commonwealth sources usually spell it clinical judgement model. Tanner's most quoted conclusion is also the least comfortable one: clinical judgments are influenced more by what the nurse brings to the situation than by the objective data in front of them. Her other four conclusions run in the same direction. Sound judgment depends partly on knowing the patient and their usual pattern of responses, it is shaped by the culture of the unit as much as by the case, nurses use several reasoning patterns rather than one, and reflection is usually triggered by a judgment that has already broken down.

Three of the four phases are unobservable. Noticing, interpreting, and reflecting all happen inside the nurse's head, and responding is the only phase a preceptor can actually watch. That is the assessment problem in one sentence, and it is why so much nursing education effort goes into getting a learner to narrate their reasoning out loud, whether in debriefing, in think-aloud exercises, or in simulation.

The NCSBN model exists because a licensure examination cannot ask about the unobservable phases and then grade an opinion. Its scored layer breaks judgment into six components, recognizing cues, analyzing cues, prioritizing hypotheses, generating solutions, taking action, and evaluating outcomes, which is a measurement decomposition rather than an account of how nurses think. Programs teach to those six because the examination does, and that imports a structure into the classroom that was chosen for psychometric reasons.

Medicine calls a closely related thing clinical reasoning, and the two literatures developed largely apart. A nursing program and a residency program can therefore be teaching the same underlying skill under different names, with different frameworks and no shared vocabulary, and an interprofessional team on the same unit ends up reasoning together using two models neither side was taught.

What this looks like in a program

  • Ask a learner to narrate the noticing and the interpreting, since responding is the only phase you can observe and it reveals the least about why they chose it.
  • Keep the measurement model and the teaching model separate. The six NCLEX components are a scoring decomposition and were not designed to structure a debrief.
  • If a program runs interprofessional simulation, settle on one vocabulary before the debriefing rather than during it.

Common questions

What are Tanner's four phases of clinical judgment?

Tanner's Clinical Judgment Model has four phases: noticing, interpreting, responding, and reflecting. Tanner drew the model from a review of nearly 200 studies and published it in the Journal of Nursing Education in 2006. Noticing, interpreting, and reflecting happen inside the nurse's head. Responding is the only phase a preceptor can watch, which is why so much of the teaching effort goes into getting a learner to narrate the reasoning out loud.

What is the difference between Tanner's model and the NCSBN clinical judgment model?

Tanner's model describes how nurses think in practice. The NCSBN Clinical Judgment Measurement Model is a separate instrument, built to score clinical judgment on a licensure examination, and it underpins the Next Generation NCLEX. Its scored layer has six components: recognizing cues, analyzing cues, prioritizing hypotheses, generating solutions, taking action, and evaluating outcomes. That list is a measurement decomposition rather than an account of how nurses think, which is why the two models are not interchangeable.

When did the Next Generation NCLEX start?

The Next Generation NCLEX launched on April 1, 2023. Its item types rest on the NCSBN Clinical Judgment Measurement Model, which scores judgment as six components: recognizing cues, analyzing cues, prioritizing hypotheses, generating solutions, taking action, and evaluating outcomes. Tanner's four-phase model, published in 2006, is a description of how nurses think, and the NCSBN model is the instrument used to score that kind of judgment on the examination.

Last updated November 2026

Put the frameworks into practice

ClinicalSim maps voice-based practice to the competency framework that fits the learner's stage.

Discuss your communication priorities