Skip to main content
ClinicalSim

Debriefing

Debriefing, in healthcare simulation, is a facilitated conversation in which people who have had an experience are led through a purposive discussion of that experience. The INACSL Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice require a planned debriefing process in every simulation-based educational activity, and they define debriefing as a bidirectional, formal, collaborative, reflective process within the simulation learning activity. The Healthcare Simulation Dictionary, third edition, lists a separate use of the word, clinical event debriefing, for a facilitated discussion after a real clinical event rather than after a simulation.

Source: INACSL Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice: The Debriefing Process (2021); Lederman, Simulation & Gaming, 1992, as quoted in the SSH Healthcare Simulation Dictionary, third edition (AHRQ Publication No. 24-0077, January 2025)

Lederman's 1992 wording, which the Healthcare Simulation Dictionary adopts, is the plain definition: people who have had an experience are led through a purposive discussion of it. INACSL's 2021 standard makes that discussion a requirement, not an optional extra. Every simulation-based educational activity must include a planned debriefing process. The standard says much learning occurs during this time, and that the session should not become another lecture.

The same standard treats debriefing as one of three related techniques, alongside feedback and guided reflection. Feedback is unidirectional: information is transferred between the learner and a facilitator, a simulator, a peer, or a device, with the aim of improving understanding or performance. Guided reflection asks the learner to explore the critical elements of the experience, sometimes through journaling or open discussion rather than only a live conversation. Debriefing is the two-way exchange. No single technique is necessarily preferential, so a program can blend them depending on the learner and the objective.

A structured debrief moves through named phases. In the description phase, learners are reminded of the objectives and the purpose of the conversation. In the reaction or defuse phase, learners say how the encounter felt. In the analysis or discovery phase, the facilitator explores the learner's thinking and surfaces gaps. In the summary or application phase, the group names insights and how they transfer to patient care. Published frameworks order the early phases differently. PEARLS opens with reactions before description.

INACSL puts weight on who runs the conversation. The process is constructed or facilitated by a person, or by a system capable of appropriate feedback, debriefing, or guided reflection. When a person leads it, the standard asks for competence in the process, familiarity with the case and the expected performance, continued professional development, and recognition by learners as a credible source. The required moves include open-ended and reflective questions, a Socratic approach, advocacy, active listening, a non-judgmental demeanor, and silence. The conversation also has to be held where privacy, open discussion, trust, and confidentiality are possible.

Debriefing after a real clinical event

Clinical event debriefing is a different job that happens to share the name. The Healthcare Simulation Dictionary, third edition, defines it as a facilitated discussion after an actual clinical event, designed to promote reflection and improve outcomes for the individual, the team, and the patient. Rose and colleagues, quoted there, describe an individual or a team formally reflecting on performance after a task, a shift, or a critical event. That conversation is about care that already happened to a real patient.

A simulation debrief is about a designed activity. The patients are simulated, the objectives were written in advance, and the point is learning rather than a review of a clinical outcome. Programs that use one word for both should say which one they mean, because the confidentiality rules, the facilitator, and what may be recorded are not the same.

PEARLS and plus-delta

PEARLS stands for Promoting Excellence And Reflective Learning in Simulation. Walter Eppich and Adam Cheng published it in Simulation in Healthcare in 2015. The four phases are reactions, description, analysis, and summary. The distinctive part is the analysis phase, where the facilitator chooses among learner self-assessment, focused facilitation, and directive feedback or teaching. The paper supplies suggested wording for each phase, which is why faculty who facilitate occasionally can use it from a script.

Plus-delta is one of those self-assessment prompts, not a rival framework. The facilitator asks what went well and what the learner would do differently next time. Cheng, Eppich, and colleagues, in Advances in Simulation in 2021, describe it as conceptually simple and easy to implement, and they argue it works best when the learner's self-assessment is set next to the facilitator's own observations. A debrief that only collects what went wrong has dropped the plus, which is the part that says why a good move worked.

What this looks like in a program

  • Schedule debriefing time in the block rather than borrowing it from the scenario. INACSL says the time has no fixed ratio to the scenario, and it has to be long enough to address the critical elements.
  • Hold the conversation where the group can speak privately. The same standard ties privacy, open discussion, trust, and confidentiality to the setting.
  • Pick one published framework and train faculty on it. PEARLS and plus-delta are both published, and a script is more reliable than a half-remembered model.

Common questions

What is debriefing in healthcare simulation?

Debriefing in healthcare simulation is a facilitated, two-way conversation about a simulation experience. INACSL's Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice, The Debriefing Process (2021), define it as a formal, collaborative, reflective process within the simulation learning activity, and require a planned debriefing process in every simulation-based educational activity. That process may include feedback, debriefing, guided reflection, or more than one of them. The standard says much learning occurs during this time, and that the session should not turn into another lecture. The Healthcare Simulation Dictionary, third edition, also lists clinical event debriefing as a separate use of the word, for a discussion after a real clinical event.

What are the phases of a simulation debrief?

INACSL's 2021 debriefing standard describes four phases. In the description phase, learners are reminded of the objectives and the purpose of the debrief. In the reaction or defuse phase, learners say how the experience felt. In the analysis or discovery phase, the facilitator helps learners explore what happened, understand the material, and identify gaps. In the summary or application phase, the group names insights and how the learning transfers to patient care. Published frameworks order the early phases differently. PEARLS, from Eppich and Cheng in Simulation in Healthcare in 2015, opens with reactions before description.

What is the difference between debriefing and feedback?

INACSL's 2021 debriefing standard treats feedback, debriefing, and guided reflection as three related techniques, and it says no single technique is necessarily preferential. Feedback is unidirectional: information is transferred between the learner and a facilitator, a simulator, a peer, or a device, with the aim of improving understanding or performance. Debriefing is bidirectional, a formal collaborative reflection. Guided reflection asks the learner to explore critical elements of the experience, sometimes in writing or in an open discussion after the event. A program can blend the three depending on the learner and the objective.

What is PEARLS debriefing?

PEARLS stands for Promoting Excellence And Reflective Learning in Simulation. Walter Eppich and Adam Cheng published the framework in Simulation in Healthcare in 2015. It has four phases: reactions, description, analysis, and summary. In the analysis phase the facilitator chooses among learner self-assessment, focused facilitation, and providing information through directive feedback or teaching. The paper supplies suggested wording for each phase. Plus-delta, asking what went well and what the learner would change, is one of the self-assessment prompts PEARLS names for that analysis phase.

What is plus-delta debriefing?

Plus-delta is a debriefing prompt that asks learners to assess their own performance in a pair: what went well, and what they would do differently next time. Cheng, Eppich, and colleagues, in Advances in Simulation in 2021, describe it as conceptually simple and easy to implement, and they argue it works best when the learner's self-assessment is set next to the facilitator's own observations. The plus items are what the learner judges to have gone well. The delta items are the changes the learner would make. In PEARLS it is one self-assessment strategy inside the analysis phase, not a separate system.

Last updated November 2026

Put the frameworks into practice

ClinicalSim maps voice-based practice to the competency framework that fits the learner's stage.

Discuss your communication priorities